“Europe needs the Convention and Europe needs the Court”
19 June 2014
Two fascinating speeches to recommend.
Lord Phillips, former Supreme Court President, gave a thoughtful speech at Kings College on whether human rights are a “force for good or a threat to democracy”. He expressed quite significant concerns over some recent Strasbourg decisions on jurisdiction, prisoner votes etc. (you know the drill – see Rosalind’s post on the other senior judges/former judges speaking their minds).
The conclusion he reaches, on balance but also with “no hesitation” is that “Europe needs the Convention and Europe needs the Court. … Strasbourg is a powerful force for good.”
I really must do a chart of the senior judiciary and ex-judiciary’s positions on Strasbourg. They are falling over themselves to express a view.
Meanwhile, over at the Law Society of Ireland, Lady Hale gave a speech on Freedom of Religion and Belief, which readers will know is one of this blog’s pet topics (see our other posts on religion).
For a contrary view see my essay on spiked: Human Rights – A Straitjacket on Liberty. Whereas natural rights celebrated democracy; human rights emasculate it.
http://www.spiked-online.com/newsite/article/human-rights-a-straitjacket-on-liberty/15222#.U6LlzvldV8G