Same-Sex Marriage, Child Protection and Extraordinary Rendition – The Human Rights Roundup

17 December 2012 by

gaycoupleWelcome back to the UK Human Rights Roundup, your weekly bulletin of human rights news. The full list of links can be found here. You can also find our table of human rights cases here and previous roundups here.

Same-sex marriage continued to dominate the news this week, with the Church making its views known on the government’s proposals.  Meanwhile, the Supreme Court has been making delicate decisions about the rights of young persons to anonymity in proceedings relating to allegations of abuse.  It would not be a newsworthy week were there not some reference to prisoner voting, and this week the UK was given a pre-emptive warning by the Council of Europe on the matter.  Finally, commentators have been anticipating the imminent publication of the findings of the Commission on a Bill of Rights.

by Daniel Isenberg

In the news

Here comes the Bill of Rights Commission report… maybe

With the report of the Commission on a Bill of Rights due to be published soon (according to the Sunday Telegraph, this Tuesday), the relationship between the Human Rights Act and any potential ‘British Bill of Rights’ is rarely out of the news. Look out for our coverage of the Commission’s report later this week.

This week, Professor Francesca Klug has argued that the Human Rights Act is a UK bill of rights “in all but name” and claims that its Conservative opposition arises not out of the rights it upholds, but its European origins (despite a heavily British authorship).  The Labour government which enacted the HRA is not without Klug’s censure, as she argues there should have been broader public education when the law was originally passed.  Meanwhile, former member of the Commission, Michael Pinto-Duschinsky, pessimistically predicts a vague report and suggests that a ‘too literal’ approach to the terms of reference will have limited the scope of the Commission’s inquiry.

Same-Sex Marriage

Following on from Adam Wagner’s pieces on this blog (here and here), the government’s proposals to legalise same-sex marriage have thrown up questions of the competing rights to freedom from discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and freedom of religious expression – see the Government’s consultation response and fact-sheet.  The Economist provides a useful outline of the debate, including the role Strasbourg may come to play in it.  Meanwhile, the Church of England has complained about the consultation process for the government’s proposals.

The UK Constitutional Law Blog provides an interesting take on this issue, examining a recent case in the Italian courts which, while not fully accepting the constitutionality of same-sex marriage, does develop the Italian courts’ understanding of the concept of ‘family’.

Child Protection and Privacy

This was also an interesting week for questions around the protection of children’s identities, and Robin Hopkins on the Panopticon blog has provided two very worthwhile reads.  The first relates to Re A (A Child) (see ‘In the Courts’ below), where the Supreme Court attempts to “reconcile the irreconcilable”, ultimately concluding that the rights to family life and a fair trial of the alleged perpetrators of abuse outweigh those to anonymity, in these particular circumstances, of the alleged victim.  Competing rights also feature in Robin Hopkins’ second post on the balance between transparency on the one hand, and the protection of children through anonymity on the other.  He argues that in cases involving serious incidents relating to children, those deciding on disclosure should err on the side of careful redaction.


With the Justice and Security Bill stirring up debate, the security services have found themselves at the centre of the news over the past few weeks, and this was no exception.

Firstly, the government has agreed to pay £2.2m to Libyan dissident Sami al-Saadi and his family, to settle his claim that MI6 were involved in his rendition from Hong Kong, following which he was tortured by the Gaddafi regime.  Nevertheless, the Foreign Office has stated that any settlement does not amount to an admission of liability.

The European Court of Human Rights has also been vocal on the issue of rendition this week, with the Grand Chamber finding in El-Masri v The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia (read press release) that the Macedonian government breached (amongst other things) Article 3 of the ECHR – the prohibition against torture and inhuman or degrading treatment – through its treatment of Khaled El-Masri, and his transfer to US authorities as part of a ‘rendition’ operation.

Kanstantsin Dzehtsiarou makes some interesting points about this decision on the ‘Human Rights in Ireland’ blog about the Court’s fact-finding role, and its choice in making such a finding against Macedonia, rather than a “more influential” member state.

The Finucane Review

The security services also made the news through the publication of the Pat Finucane Review, which looked at the possible complicity of the UK government in the murder of a Belfast solicitor by loyalist paramilitaries; the summary and chief findings of which can be found here.  Colin Murray observes that the report does not blame UK government ministers for the approach taken to security at the time, though reads this latest publication in the light of earlier reviews by Lord Stevens and Peter Cory, as revealing certain state agencies as ‘turning a blind eye’ to some loyalist paramilitary activity.

Litvinenko Inquest

Joshua Rozenberg has provided a useful analysis of the issues raised by the current Alexander Litvinenko inquest – central among these will be Sir Robert Owen’s views on whether Article 2 of the ECHR is engaged: did the UK government fail in a duty to protect Litvinenko’s ‘right to life’?

Also in the News

Alex Bailin QC on the Inforrm Blog has highlighted the Law Commission’s consultation on reform of contempt of court, and his criticisms of the proposals are well worth a read: ranging from trials for ‘juror research’ not being by jury, to his thoughts on whether such an issue is realistically able to be managed.

Whilst the Home Secretary has been making a speech on immigration, and her views on why it should be controlled, the High Court has held that where the applicant cannot afford the fee, charging for a human rights-based immigration application may be a breach of human rights in itself.

Prisoner voting has managed to make the news once again this week, with the Council of Europe gently nudging the UK by issuing a formal reminder of its duties to implement decisions of the Court.  However, the issue will not be revisited until next September.

Some other interesting thoughts this week are provided by Michael Uberoi on the makeup of the Hillsborough Independent Panel rather than a judicial inquiry; Ashley Hurst also delivers his thoughts on the Joint Committee on Human Rights’ report on the Defamation Bill; and the ever-fascinating ‘Without Prejudice’ podcast this week focuses on same-sex marriage, Labour’s ‘Leveson Bill’, secret courts, and plans to reform judicial review.

In the courts

R (Press Association) v Cambridge Crown Court [2012] EWCA Crim 2434 – Judge orders anonymisation of a convicted rapist in order to protect the identity of his victim

A (A Child) [2012] UKSC 60 – Social work records of allegedly abused woman should be disclosed in child proceedings where her alleged abuser is the father

X v Mid Sussex Citizens Advice Bureau & Anor [2012] UKSC 59 – Volunteers not entitled to disability discrimination protection as volunteer activities are not an “occupation” with the meaning of the EU Framework Directive -[see also summary here]

The British Humanist Association & Anor v London Borough of Richmond Upon Thames & Ors [2012] EWHC 3622 (Admin) –  British Humanist Society loses High Court challenge to building of Catholic state school in Twickenham –  [see also Rosalind English’s blog post here]

Upcoming Events

The UKHRB now has an additional feature on the right sidebar of the website – the events list. To add events to this list, email Adam Wagner. Please only send events which (i) have their own webpage which can be linked to, and (ii) are relevant to topics covered by the blog.

UKHRB posts

Sign up to free human rights updates by email, Facebook, Twitter or RSS

Welcome to the UKHRB

This blog is run by 1 Crown Office Row barristers' chambers. Subscribe for free updates here. The blog's editorial team is:
Commissioning Editor: Jonathan Metzer
Editorial Team: Rosalind English
Angus McCullough QC David Hart QC
Martin Downs
Jim Duffy

Free email updates

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog for free and receive weekly notifications of new posts by email.




7/7 Bombings 9/11 A1P1 Aarhus Abortion Abu Qatada Abuse Access to justice adoption AI air pollution air travel ALBA Allergy Al Qaeda Amnesty International animal rights Animals anonymity Article 1 Protocol 1 Article 2 article 3 Article 4 article 5 Article 6 Article 8 Article 9 article 10 Article 11 article 13 Article 14 article 263 TFEU Artificial Intelligence Asbestos Assange assisted suicide asylum asylum seekers Australia autism badgers benefits Bill of Rights biotechnology birds directive blogging Bloody Sunday brexit Bribery British Waterways Board Catholic Church Catholicism Chagos Islanders Charter of Fundamental Rights child protection Children children's rights China christianity citizenship civil liberties campaigners civil partnerships climate change clinical negligence closed material procedure Coercion Commission on a Bill of Rights common buzzard common law communications competition confidentiality confiscation order conscientious objection consent conservation constitution contact order contempt of court Control orders Copyright coronavirus costs costs budgets Court of Protection crime criminal law Cybersecurity Damages data protection death penalty defamation DEFRA deportation deprivation of liberty derogations Detention Dignitas diplomacy disability disclosure Discrimination disease divorce DNA domestic violence duty of care ECHR ECtHR Education election Employment Environment Equality Act Equality Act 2010 Ethiopia EU EU Charter of Fundamental Rights EU costs EU law European Convention on Human Rights European Court of Human Rights European Court of Justice evidence extradition extraordinary rendition Facebook Family Fatal Accidents Fertility FGM Finance fishing rights foreign criminals foreign office foreign policy France freedom of assembly Freedom of Expression freedom of information freedom of speech game birds Gay marriage gay rights Gaza Gender genetics Germany Google government Grenfell grooming Gun Control gwyneth paltrow gypsies habitats habitats protection happy new year Hardeep Singh Harkins and Edwards Health HIV HJ Iran HM (Iraq) v The Secretary of state for the home department [2010] EWCA Civ 1322 Holder holkham beach holocaust Home Office Home Office v Tariq Hounslow v Powell House of Commons Housing housing benefits Howard League for Penal Reform how judges decide cases hra damages claim HRLA HS2 hs2 challenge hts Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority human rights Human Rights Act Human Rights Act 1998 human rights advocacy Human rights and the UK constitution human rights commission human rights conventions human rights damages Human Rights Day human rights decisions Human Rights Information Project human rights news Human Rights Watch human right to education human trafficking hunting Huntington's Disease HXA hyper injunctions Igor Sutyagin immigration Immigration/Extradition Immigration Act 2014 immigration appeals immigration detention immigration judge immigration rules immunity India Indonesia Infrastructure Planning Committee Inhuman and degrading treatment injunction Inquest Inquests insurance insurmountable obstacles intelligence services act intercept evidence interception interim remedies international international criminal court international law international treaty obligations internet internet service providers internship inuit investigation investigative duty Iran Iranian nuclear program Iraq Iraqi asylum seeker Iraq War Ireland irrationality islam Israel Italy iTunes IVF ivory ban jackson reforms Janowiec and Others v Russia ( Japan Jason Smith Jeet Singh Jeremy Corbyn jeremy hunt job Jogee John Hemming John Terry joint enterprise joint tenancy Jon Guant Joseph v Spiller journalism judaism Judges and Juries judging Judicial activism judicial brevity judicial deference judicial review Judicial Review reform judiciary Julian Assange jurisdiction jury trial JUSTICE Justice and Security Act Justice and Security Bill Justice and Security Green Paper Justice Human Rights Awards JUSTICE Human Rights Awards 2010 just satisfaction Katyn Massacre Kay v Lambeth Kay v UK Ken Clarke Kerry McCarthy Kettling Kings College koran burning Labour Lady Hale LASPO Law Pod UK Law Society of Scotland leave to enter leave to remain legal aid legal aid cuts legal blogs Legal Certainty legal naughty step Legal Ombudsman legal representation legitimate expectation let as a dwelling Leveson Inquiry Levi Bellfield lewisham hospital closure lgbtq liability Libel libel reform Liberty library closures Libya licence conditions licence to shoot life sentence limestone pavements lisbon treaty Lithuania Litigation litvinenko live exports local authorities locked in syndrome London Legal Walk London Probation Trust Lord Bingham Lord Blair Lord Goldsmith lord irvine Lord Judge speech Lord Kerr Lord Lester Lord Neuberger Lord Phillips Lord Taylor luftur rahman MAGA Magna Carta mail on sunday Majority Verdict Malcolm Kennedy malice Margaret Thatcher Margin of Appreciation Maria Gallastegui marriage material support maternity pay Matthew Woods Mba v London Borough Of Merton McKenzie friend Media and Censorship Medical medical negligence medical records medicine mental capacity Mental Capacity Act Mental Capacity Act 2005 Mental Health mental health act mental health advocacy mental health awareness Mental illness merits review MGN v UK michael gove Midwives migrant crisis military Milly Dowler Ministerial Code Ministry of Justice Ministry of Justice cuts misfeasance in public office modern slavery morality morocco mortuaries motherhood Moulton Mousa MP expenses Mr Gul Mr Justice Eady MS (Palestinian Territories) (FC) (Appellant) v Secretary of State for the Home Department murder music Musician's Union Muslim NADA v. SWITZERLAND - 10593/08 - HEJUD [2012] ECHR 1691 naked rambler Naomi Campbell nationality National Pro Bono Week national security Natural England nature conservation naturism Nazi negligence Neuberger neuroscience news new Supreme Court President NHS NHS Risk Register Nicklinson Niqaab Noise Regulations 2005 Northern Ireland nuclear challenges nuisance nursing nursing home Obituary Occupy London Offensive Speech oil spill olympics open justice oppress OPQ v BJM orchestra Osama Bin Laden paramountcy principle parental rights parenthood parliamentary expenses parliamentary expenses scandal Parliament square parole board pastor Terry Jones patents Pathway Students Patrick Quinn murder Pensions persecution Personal Injury personality rights perversity PF and EF v UK Phil Woolas phone hacking phone taps physical and mental disabilities physician assisted death Pinnock Piracy Plagiarism planning planning system plebgate POCA podcast points Poland Police police investigations police liability police powers police state police surveillance Policy Exchange report political judges Politics Politics/Public Order poor reporting Pope portal possession proceedings post office power of attorney PoW letters to ministers pre-nup pre-nuptial Pre-trial detention predator control pregnancy press press briefing press freedom Prince Charles prince of wales princess caroline of monaco principle of subsidiarity prior restraint prison Prisoners prisoners rights prisoners voting prisoner vote prisoner votes Prisons prison vote privacy privacy injunction privacy law through the front door Private life private nuisance private use proceeds of crime Professional Discipline Property proportionality prosecution Protection of Freedoms Act Protection of Freedoms Bill Protest protest camp protest rights Protocol 15 psychiatric hospitals Public/Private public access publication public authorities Public Bodies Bill public inquiries public interest public interest environmental litigation public interest immunity Public Order Public Sector Equality Duty quango quantum quarantine Queen's Speech queer in the 21st century R (on the application of EH) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2012] EWHC 2569 (Admin) Rabone and another v Pennine Care NHS Foundation Trust [2012] UKSC 2 race relations Rachel Corrie Radicalisation Radmacher Ramsgate raptors rehabilitation Reith Lectures Religion resuscitation RightsInfo right to die right to family life right to life Right to Privacy right to swim riots Roma Romania Round Up Royals Russia saudi arabia Scotland secrecy secret justice Secret trials security services sexual offence Sikhism Smoking social media social workers South Africa south african constitution Spain special advocates spending cuts Sports Standing starvation statelessness stem cells stop and search Strasbourg sumption super injunctions Supreme Court Supreme Court of Canada surrogacy surveillance Syria Tax Taxi technology Terrorism terrorism act tort Torture travel treason treaty accession trial by jury TTIP Turkey Twitter UK Ukraine universal jurisdiction unlawful detention USA US Supreme Court vicarious liability Wales War Crimes Wars Welfare Western Sahara Whistleblowing Wikileaks wildlife wind farms WomenInLaw Worboys wrongful birth YearInReview Zimbabwe


This blog is maintained for information purposes only. It is not intended to be a source of legal advice and must not be relied upon as such. Blog posts reflect the views and opinions of their individual authors, not of chambers as a whole.

Our privacy policy can be found on our ‘subscribe’ page or by clicking here.

%d bloggers like this: