This post originally displayed an image of a sign at Stepping Hill Hospital, including reference to Stockport NHS Foundation Trust. The case did not involve Stockport NHSFT so I have removed the image: my apologies for any confusion caused. In the absence of any interesting images of Pennine Care NHS Trust, who were the Respondent, [...]
Archive for the ‘Case summaries’ Category
Times contempt challenge thrown out in Strasbourg
Posted in Art. 10 | Freedom of Expression, Art. 6 | Right to Fair Trial, Case summaries, European, Media, tagged contempt of court, contempt of court act on February 8, 2012 | 1 Comment »
Michael Alexander SECKERSON and TIMES NEWSPAPERS LIMITED against the UK Applications nos. 32844/10 and 33510/10 – Read decision / press release The European Court of Human Rights has rejected as “inadmissible” Times Newspaper’s challenge to its 2009 conviction for contempt of court. The decision, which was made by six judges, is a good example of [...]
Axel Springer and Von Hannover: Grand Chamber victory for media – Inforrm
Posted in Art. 10 | Freedom of Expression, Art. 8 | Right to Privacy/Family, Case summaries, European, Margin of Appreciation, Media, tagged axel springer, European Court of Human Rights, Freedom of Expression on February 7, 2012 | Leave a Comment »
The media were successful in both the judgments handed down this morning by the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights. The judgments made it clear that the right to privacy has to be carefully balanced against contribution which a publication makes to a debate of general interest. In both cases, taking account [...]
Are lawyers in right-to-die cases breaking the law?
Posted in Art. 2 | Right to life, Art. 6 | Right to Fair Trial, Art. 9 | Thought/Conscience/Religion, Case summaries, Criminal, Disciplinary Proceedings, Medical, tagged assisting suicide, suicide act 1961 on January 31, 2012 | Leave a Comment »
Philip Havers QC of 1 Crown Office Row is representing Martin in the judicial review proceedings. He is not the author of this post. Albert Camus famously wrote: ‘there is but one truly serious philosophical problem and that is suicide.’ However profound a philosophical problem, the question of suicide or, more precisely, assisted suicide is proving quite [...]
R (Associated Newspapers) v Lord Justice Leveson: Challenge to Anonymity Ruling Dismissed
Posted in Art. 10 | Freedom of Expression, Case summaries, Freedom of Information, Inquests and Inquiries, Media, tagged associated newspapers on January 22, 2012 | Comments Off
Associated Newspapers Ltd, R (on the application of) v Rt Hon Lord Justice Leveson [2012] EWHC 57 – Read judgment On Friday 20 January 2012 the Administrative Court dismissed the second application for judicial review of the Leveson Inquiry. The Court dismissed an application by Associated Newspapers (supported by the Daily Telegraph) to quash the [...]
Metropolitan Police succeed in G20 “kettling” appeal
Posted in Art. 10 | Freedom of Expression, Art. 11 | Freedom of Association, Case summaries, Criminal, Police, tagged G20 protest, Kettling on January 19, 2012 | 2 Comments »
R (on the application of Hannah McClure and Joshua Moos) v The Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [2012] EWCA Civ 12 – Read judgment The Metropolitan Police has succeeded in its appeal against a Divisional Court ruling (see previous post) that the use of crowd control measures – in this case, containment or “kettling” – [...]
Everything’s free in America (copyrighted material not included)
Posted in Art. 5 | Right to Liberty, Art. 6 | Right to Fair Trial, Art. 8 | Right to Privacy/Family, Case law, Case summaries, Criminal, In the news, International, Technology, tagged Copyright, extradition act, Piracy, Richard O'Dwyer on January 18, 2012 | Comments Off
The Government of the United States of America -v- O’Dwyer, Westminster Magistrates’ Court – Read judgment It seems appropriate, on the day when Wikipedia shut down for 24 hours to protest against US anti-piracy legislation, to talk about piracy (in the copyright sense) and what role human rights law has to play in the perpetual battle [...]
Injunction 4 sex pics on mob
Posted in Art. 10 | Freedom of Expression, Art. 8 | Right to Privacy/Family, Case comments, Case summaries, In the news, Technology, tagged super injunctions on January 12, 2012 | 1 Comment »
AMP v Persons unknown – read judgment If you lose your mobile phone with highly confidential and private information on it, all may not be lost. The unscrupulous finder may be prevented from blurting its contents all over the web, even if the identity of that person is unknown to you or the court. It [...]
What price unfair dismissal, in times of austerity?
Posted in Art. 6 | Right to Fair Trial, Case law, Case summaries, Costs and Procedure, Disciplinary Proceedings, Employment on December 17, 2011 | Comments Off
Edwards v Chesterfield Royal Hospital and Botham (FC) v Ministry of Defence [2011] UKSC 58 – read judgment. Although not strictly speaking a human rights case, the Supreme Court handed down an important employment law decision this week which has significant impact on employees’ ability to claim damages if they are sacked unfairly or if [...]
A human right to object to war
Posted in Art. 9 | Thought/Conscience/Religion, Case summaries, In the news, Politics / Public Order, Religion on December 13, 2011 | 7 Comments »
R v Michael Peter Lyons [2011] EWCA Crim 2808- read judgment Moral objections to the UK’s involvement in Afghanistan do not constitute a defence to an insubordination charge, the Court Martial Appeal Court has ruled. The appellant was not entitled to disobey a lawful command on the ground of conscientious objection. At the age of [...]
What to do with ‘cold cases’ when they eventually heat up
Posted in Art. 7 | Retrospective Punishment, Case law, Case summaries, Criminal, In the news on December 8, 2011 | 3 Comments »
R v. H & others [2011] EWCA Crim 2753 – read judgment. One of the most popular ideas in crime fiction is the ‘cold case’; the apparently unsolved crime which, through various twists and turns, is brought to justice many years after it was committed. Indeed, at least two recent long-running TV dramas (the American [...]
Successful challenge to library closures: lip service not enough for equality duties – Shaheen Rahman
Posted in Art. 14 | Anti-Discrimination, Case summaries, Children, Spending cuts on November 24, 2011 | 1 Comment »
R (Green and others) v GLOUCESTERSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL & SOMERSET COUNTY COUNCIL [2011] EWHC 2687 (Admin) – Read judgment In the administrative court, the decisions of two local authorities to withdraw funding for library services were held to be unlawful. The court held that the withdrawal of a local library might indirectly discriminate against people [...]
Investigation team “lacks necessary independence” for MOD ill-treatment allegations
Posted in Art. 2 | Right to life, Art. 3 | Torture / Inhumane Treatment, Case summaries, Inquests and Inquiries, Politics / Public Order, Technology on November 23, 2011 | 1 Comment »
Ali Zaki Mousa v Secretary of State for Defence & Anr [2011] EWCA Civ 133 - read judgment Philip Havers QC of 1 Crown Office Row represented the respondent secretary of state in this case. He is not the author of this post. The Court of Appeal has ruled that the Iraq Historic Allegations [...]
How private are patients’ dental records?
Posted in Art. 6 | Right to Fair Trial, Art. 8 | Right to Privacy/Family, Case summaries, Disciplinary Proceedings, Medical, tagged human rights on November 21, 2011 | 1 Comment »
This is a case in which Philip Havers QC of 1 Crown Office Row appeared for the General Dental Council; he is not the author of this post. The General Dental Council v Savery and others [2011] EWHC 3011 (Admin) – Read judgment Mr Justice Sales in the High Court has ruled that the General [...]
Welcome!
Browse by legal topic
Recommended- The Fat Tax - Daniel Barnett - Dale & Co. February 9, 2012
- Case Law: Axel Springer v Germany, Grand Chamber finds violation of Article 10 – Sara Mansoori February 9, 2012
- Supreme Court decision on Rabone v Pennine Care NHS Trust - Hempsons February 9, 2012
- T, R (on the application of) v Greater Manchester Police & Anor [2012] EWHC 147 (Admin) (09 February 2012) February 9, 2012Student fails in human rights challenge to Enhanced Criminal Records Certificate with warning incurred when he was 11 for theft of 2 bicycles
- Strasbourg Rulings on Two Personal Privacy Claims February 8, 2012
- Open Justice « 2drj February 8, 2012
- Wigs off, jeans on at the Judicial College | Joshua Rozenberg | Law | guardian.co.uk February 8, 2012
- Contempt laws are still valid in the internet age | Dominic Grieve February 8, 2012
- Case law
- T, R (on the application of) v Greater Manchester Police & Anor [2012] EWHC 147 (Admin) (09 February 2012) February 9, 2012Student fails in human rights challenge to Enhanced Criminal Records Certificate with warning incurred when he was 11 for theft of 2 bicycles
- Othman v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2012] UKSIAC B1 (6 February 2012) February 8, 2012Terrorist suspect Abu Qatada granted bail on strict conditions. However, Secretary of State must show evidence of progress in his deportation in next 3 months then deprivation of liberty will no longer be justifiable.
- AT v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2012] EWCA Civ 42 (07 February 2012) February 7, 2012Control order of member of Libyan Islamic Fighting Group ruled unlawful as wasn't given enough information about case against him as mandated in A v UK
- Moussaoui, R (on the application of) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2012] EWHC 126 (Admin) (03 February 2012) February 6, 2012Detention of Mentally ill foreign criminal pending deportation was unlawful as regular reviews not carried out. Given damages of £1
- Coogan v News Group Newspapers Ltd & Anor [2012] EWCA Civ 48 February 1, 2012Investigator Glen Mulcaire loses self-incrimination appeal against order that he should reveal phone hacking clients.
- D and S, R (on the application of) v Manchester City Council [2012] EWHC 17 (Admin) (12 January 2012) January 31, 2012Chalenge by 2 elderly disabled people to £17m adult social care cuts by Manchester City Council fails. Consultation and regard to equality duties adequate.
- T, R (on the application of) v Greater Manchester Police & Anor [2012] EWHC 147 (Admin) (09 February 2012) February 9, 2012
-
UKHRB on Twitter
- RT @SkyNewsBreak: David Cameron has spoken to King Abdullah of Jordan to try to extradite radical cleric Abu Qatada 24 minutes ago
- RT @daniel_barnett: Here's what I REALLY think about the Stott case - http://t.co/gCIHyevb. @AdamWagner1 also has excellent piece at htt ... 1 hour ago
- Congrats to @1crownofficerow's Martin Forde QC, to fill Judicial Appointments Commission vacancy left by Lord Sumption http://t.co/wu7yVWAx 2 hours ago
- RT @INFORRM: Case Law: Axel Springer v Germany, Grand Chamber finds violation of Article 10 - Sara Mansoori http://t.co/r5pBIQU3 2 hours ago
- ... would have found that but for case law! Mr Justice Parker inviting Court of Appeal / Supreme Court to bite the bullet here 2 hours ago
- ... also gives permission to appeal. Wld have found scheme "provides no mechanism for review.. disproportionate.. not compatible with A8.".. 2 hours ago
- ... police warning were for theft of 2 bicycles when 11, student now 20. High Court judge "reluctantly" finds no breach of article 8... 2 hours ago
- Recent posts
- Abu Qatada relased on “very restrictive” bail conditions February 9, 2012 Rosalind English
- Please stow your rights in the overhead compartment February 9, 2012 Rosalind English
- Hospital had human rights duty to protect voluntary patient from suicide, rules Supreme Court February 8, 2012 Adam Wagner
- Libya employee can sue for dismissal in UK February 8, 2012 Rosalind English
- Times contempt challenge thrown out in Strasbourg February 8, 2012 Adam Wagner
- Indefinite detention: not very British February 8, 2012 freemovement
- UK Supreme Court is tweeting, but where are the other courts? February 7, 2012 Adam Wagner
- Axel Springer and Von Hannover: Grand Chamber victory for media – Inforrm February 7, 2012 1 Crown Office Row
Disclaimer
Youth restraint challenge rejected by High Court
Posted in Art. 3 | Torture / Inhumane Treatment, Art. 8 | Right to Privacy/Family, Case comments, Case summaries, Children, In the news, Poor reporting, Prisons, tagged Access to justice, Standing on January 16, 2012 | 1 Comment »
The Children’s Rights Alliance for England (CRAE) v Secretary of State for Justice and G4S Care and Justice Services (UK) Ltd and Serco plc [2012] EWHC 8 (Admin) – read judgment Although certain restraining measures had been taken unlawfully against young people in secure training centres for a number of years, the court had no jurisdiction [...]
Read Full Post »